Skip to content
Catholic Herald flag

Madison Catholic Herald Archive (2001-2025)

Official newspaper of the Diocese of Madison, Wisconsin

  • News
    • Around the Diocese
    • State News
    • National-World
    • Obituaries
    • Older Editions
    • Diocese of Madison’s 75th anniversary
  • Bishop
    • Bishop Hying’s Columns
    • Bishop Hying’s Letters
    • Bishop’s Schedule
    • About Bishop Hying
    • About Bishop Morlino
    • About Bishop Bullock
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Letters to the editor
    • Columns
    • Columns by name and author
  • Faith
    • Faith
    • Year of Faith
    • Faith Alive
  • Calendar
  • Obituaries
    • Clergy obituaries
    • Religious obituaries
    • Lay person obituaries
  • Multimedia
  • Advertising
    • Advertise with Us
      • Ad Policies
      • Ad Specifications
      • Classifieds Information
    • Rates & Specs (PDF)
    • Special Section Calendar (PDF)
  • About
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Links
    • Catholic Herald Promotion Materials
    • Rates & Specs (PDF)
    • Subscriptions
  • Youth
  • Español
 
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • Letters to the editor
  • Gun proponents offer similar arguments as abortion lobby
  • Letters to the editor

Gun proponents offer similar arguments as abortion lobby

On August 4, 2016
Monica Simpson

To the editor:

I was proud of Mary Uhler’s stance that we should work for stronger gun control.

Last week’s Mailbag had two letters refuting gun control positions. I would guess that both men are strong in their faith and I would guess that neither supports abortion. But both letters troubled me in that they reminded me of the abortion lobby’s arguments.

The first letter posited that gun control laws would do nothing to control crime and would in fact erode rights of gun owners. We should not touch them.

The abortion lobby argues that any restrictions on abortion (up to nine months, terminating the disabled, selective sex abortion) would erode women’s rights. They argue that any restrictions will send women to their deaths in the back alley.

The solution of the letter writer was to do things to improve society without touching guns. But are there really no improvements to be made in current gun laws? Really?

The abortion lobby does not want abortion touched and does the same thing with its advocacy of contraception. If they cared more about women’s lives, would they not cry out more over the forced abortions in China?

The second letter claims that this is an issue with society, a.k.a people kill people/not guns. It claims that if God were more a part of our lives this would not be happening (well, I do agree with this).

This is not reality and it is not reality any time soon, though we can all do our part. But the first claim reminded me of the abortion lobby. They say, “if you don’t want an abortion, don’t have one,” dismissing the struggles of post abortive women and men. That is a reality they mock and prefer to sweep under the carpet.

Gun violence is more prevalent in this country than in those with stricter gun laws. That is just a fact. We cannot dismiss facts in the face of our party loyalties.

These arguments should give us pause. Lives are at stake in abortion and lives are at stake in gun control.

Monica Simpson, Madison

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
In Letters to the editorIn abortion , crime , gun control , gun owners , guns , restrictions on abortion

Post navigation

Novena encourages praying Rosary
Right to bear arms rooted in Constitution; abortion is not

This webite, madisoncatholicheraldarchive.org, covers Catholic Herald content from October 11, 2001 to September 18, 2008 (HTML-based website) and September 19, 2008 to October 8, 2025 (WordPress-based website).

To view content prior to 9/19/2008, browse our older editions (FreeFind site search no longer available).

To search content from 9/19/2008 to 10/8/2025, use the search box above.

For newer content, please visit madisoncatholicherald.org (FAITH Catholic-based website).

e-Edition:

click to go to the Catholic Herald e-Edition

Access our e-Edition here. For more information, contact the Catholic Herald office at 608-821-3070 or email: info@madisoncatholicherald.org

Most popular:

  • A higher standard than for cats and dogs
  • Msgr. Gerard Healy to retire, celebration May 27
  • Viewing the Second Vatican Council
  • Hopes Church will continue to offer Mass in both rites
  • Green Bay Packers honor Tom Murphy

Bishop Hying’s videos:

'A Moment with the Bishop' videos on YouTube

Promote the Catholic Herald:

click for Catholic Herald promotion materials

Click here for information and materials to promote the Catholic Herald in your parish.

RSS feeds

RSS feed

You May Like

  • Letters to the editor
Eugene Hruby
On December 12, 2012

An addendum to your good editorial on the Rosary

  • Letters to the editor
Bob Crawford, Sun Prairie
On March 18, 2010

Modern liturgy is gift from Holy Spirit, joyful experience

  • Letters to the editor
James Pawlak, West Allis
On August 27, 2009

Plan should not include tax dollars for abortions

  • Letters to the editor
  • Opinion
Catholic Herald Staff
On September 22, 2021September 20, 2021

What ‘freedom’ means to me

  • Letters to the editor
Gregory L. Sheehy M.D.
On December 14, 2011

Facts about guns are difficult to ignore

  • Letters to the editor
Hal Joyce
On May 23, 2013

God forgives servers and others who make mistakes

Copyright © 2001-2025 Diocese of Madison, Catholic Herald. All rights reserved.
Website created by Leemark.com and Catholic Herald staff using Telegram theme.