Skip to content
Catholic Herald flag

Madison Catholic Herald Archive (2001-2025)

Official newspaper of the Diocese of Madison, Wisconsin

  • News
    • Around the Diocese
    • State News
    • National-World
    • Obituaries
    • Older Editions
    • Diocese of Madison’s 75th anniversary
  • Bishop
    • Bishop Hying’s Columns
    • Bishop Hying’s Letters
    • Bishop’s Schedule
    • About Bishop Hying
    • About Bishop Morlino
    • About Bishop Bullock
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Letters to the editor
    • Columns
    • Columns by name and author
  • Faith
    • Faith
    • Year of Faith
    • Faith Alive
  • Calendar
  • Obituaries
    • Clergy obituaries
    • Religious obituaries
    • Lay person obituaries
  • Multimedia
  • Advertising
    • Advertise with Us
      • Ad Policies
      • Ad Specifications
      • Classifieds Information
    • Rates & Specs (PDF)
    • Special Section Calendar (PDF)
  • About
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Links
    • Catholic Herald Promotion Materials
    • Rates & Specs (PDF)
    • Subscriptions
  • Youth
  • Español
 
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • Letters to the editor
  • Thoughts on Mass before and after Vatican II
  • Letters to the editor

Thoughts on Mass before and after Vatican II

On September 7, 2017
Tom Roberts

To the editor:

While not yet Catholic, I attended many Latin Masses before Vatican II. The formal beauty and solemnity of the processions, the cross, the priest’s vestments — all inspired reverence.

I followed the spoken Latin, although not all of it was audible. Many parishioners not understanding Latin prayed the Rosary, following which they received Communion on the tongue, kneeling at a rail.

Many of the rubrics we treat as devotions were instituted by the emperor Diocletian. Processionals and recessionals, vestments, the bishop’s cathedra on the dais were drawn from Diocletian’s court.

Kneeling to receive Communion originated in the act of submission to Diocletian, who had appropriated this  practice from contemporary Persian emperors. That brings up the question: to whom are we kneeling?

When I became a Catholic in 2000, I found a more welcoming Mass, one of participation and attention by parishioners, more akin to the celebration of communal life described in Acts 2:42-47.

As for Latin, it could be taught as Hebrew is in Judaism. In the traditional Mass, even the Scriptures could be read in Latin and understood, bringing an end to the disconnect.

Tom Roberts, Madison

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
In Letters to the editorIn communion , diocletian , hebrew , judaism , kneeling , Latin , Latin Mass , Scriptures , tom roberts , Vatican II

Post navigation

Support hurricane relief
Day of Remembrance for aborted children

This webite, madisoncatholicheraldarchive.org, covers Catholic Herald content from October 11, 2001 to September 18, 2008 (HTML-based website) and September 19, 2008 to October 8, 2025 (WordPress-based website).

To view content prior to 9/19/2008, browse our older editions (FreeFind site search no longer available).

To search content from 9/19/2008 to 10/8/2025, use the search box above.

For newer content, please visit madisoncatholicherald.org (FAITH Catholic-based website).

e-Edition:

click to go to the Catholic Herald e-Edition

Access our e-Edition here. For more information, contact the Catholic Herald office at 608-821-3070 or email: info@madisoncatholicherald.org

Most popular:

  • Priest appointments, May 2024
  • Chapter of Legatus being chartered in Madison for Catholic business leaders
  • Msgr. Gerard Healy to retire, celebration May 27
  • A rose by any other name
  • Holiness: most important form of evangelization

Bishop Hying’s videos:

'A Moment with the Bishop' videos on YouTube

Promote the Catholic Herald:

click for Catholic Herald promotion materials

Click here for information and materials to promote the Catholic Herald in your parish.

RSS feeds

RSS feed

You May Like

  • Letters to the editor
Tim Huegerich, Madison
On June 25, 2009

Look at method of saints to fund Multicultural Center

  • Letters to the editor
M. Susan Hundt-Bergan
On November 7, 2012

Appreciates music column

  • Letters to the editor
David Stiennon
On December 7, 2011

Personhood amendment promotes helpful discussion

  • Letters to the editor
Karen Wasserburger
On November 22, 2017

What divides us is more than unites us

  • Letters to the editor
Fr. John Zuhlsdorf
On October 25, 2012September 6, 2023

Church gives directives about liturgical music

  • Letters to the editor
Elaine H. Shaw
On February 17, 2016

More people should sign petition to abolish mandate

Copyright © 2001-2025 Diocese of Madison, Catholic Herald. All rights reserved.
Website created by Leemark.com and Catholic Herald staff using Telegram theme.